I decided to undertake the project of stripping and refinishing the chair. It's a great piece of furniture (solid wood and extremely well-made) and I would like for it to remain in the family forever. I wish I had a picture of it with the white paint...
Anyway, I started by using Citrustrip because I didn't want to work with something too harsh. A year or two ago I got most of the white paint off, but there were some stubborn spots. So this year I opted for the harsher stuff and went ahead and stripped the whole thing again. This time, with the aid of a brass wire brush, the old finish came out and so did the stubborn white paint. After some more sanding, a final rubdown with mineral spirits and a fine grade steel wool, and a careful once-over with a tack cloth, this thing was ready to be finished. Here it is pre-finish:
I decided to finish the chair with an oil finish (I used Watco Danish Oil, walnut color stain) because it's forgiving, quick, user-friendly, and more natural than something like polyurethane.
Here is the chair post-finish:
Once again, I wish I had a picture of it before. It truly is an amazing transformation. One of these days I'll sew a cushion for it, too.